28 gift ideas

Unisex White Elephant Gift Ideas

The short answer

The best unisex White Elephant gifts are cozy, edible or just plain fun: a weighted stuffed animal, a heated eye mask, a Stanley tumbler, a Tamagotchi, a box of freeze-dried candy or a rechargeable hand warmer. Skip anything with a size, a scent or a hobby attached, and pick something the whole room would be happy to take home.

Last updated

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links open Amazon search results so you can compare current options and prices. Affiliate disclosure.

In a mixed group you never know who ends up with your gift. It could be your boss, your cousin’s new partner or the teenager who got dragged along. A unisex gift is one that every one of them would be glad to unwrap.

These ideas are picked for exactly that. Each card has a steal rating from 1 to 5, and the price buttons show only your budget. Prices change a lot in December, so check the price on Amazon before you buy.

Short on time? Start with these 4.

  1. Top pick

    Weighted stuffed animal

    A plush with a little weight to it that feels calming to hold. Teens, grandparents and the person who swears they don’t like plush all want it.

    Idea 1 ↓
  2. Biggest laugh

    Emotional support pickle

    A smiling plush pickle with its own little card. Gets the laugh, then quietly moves into someone’s desk drawer.

    Idea 4 ↓
  3. Most practical

    Rechargeable hand warmers (pair)

    Two pocket warmers that double as small power banks. Commuters, dog walkers and sports parents will all use them this week.

    Idea 9 ↓
  4. Best value

    Hot cocoa bomb gift set

    Drop one in hot milk and it melts open into cocoa and marshmallows. Kids and adults both crowd round to watch.

    Idea 7 ↓

All 28 ideas. Pick a price.

  1. 01Top pick$30–50

    Weighted stuffed animal

    Up all fall

    A plush with a little weight to it that feels calming to hold. Teens, grandparents and the person who swears they don’t like plush all want it.

    Steal rating: 5 out of 5

  2. 02$20–30

    Heated eye mask

    Rising search

    Warm, rechargeable and great for headaches, flights and naps. Searches are climbing fast this fall.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  3. 03$30–50

    Stanley Quencher tumbler (40 oz)

    200K+ ratings

    The tumbler that started the cup craze, in a color anyone would carry. Keeps ice for hours and fits a car cup holder.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  4. 04Biggest laugh$10–20

    Emotional support pickle

    Gag-gift staple

    A smiling plush pickle with its own little card. Gets the laugh, then quietly moves into someone’s desk drawer.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  5. 05$10–20

    Porch goose outfit

    Porch goose boom

    A holiday outfit for the concrete porch goose that seems to be on every other doorstep now. Searches for goose outfits have grown about five times since last winter. If the winner has no goose yet, the under $100 list has one.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  6. 06$10–20

    Original Tamagotchi

    Comeback toy

    The 90s pocket pet, back on store shelves. Adults who had one and kids who didn’t both want it. Look for the Bandai brand name to get a real one.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  7. 07Best value$10–20

    Hot cocoa bomb gift set

    1K+ bought a month

    Drop one in hot milk and it melts open into cocoa and marshmallows. Kids and adults both crowd round to watch.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  8. 08$10–20

    Ghirardelli peppermint bark

    5K+ bought a month

    Ghirardelli’s limited-edition holiday bark, back for the season. Food is the safest unisex gift there is, and this one rarely makes it home unopened.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  9. 09Most practical$20–30

    Rechargeable hand warmers (pair)

    Two pocket warmers that double as small power banks. Commuters, dog walkers and sports parents will all use them this week.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  10. 10$30–50

    Wearable blanket

    One size fits everyone, which makes it the perfect unisex gift. Whoever opens it puts it on before the next turn.

    Steal rating: 5 out of 5

  11. 11Under $10

    Freeze-dried Jolly Ranchers

    Familiar candy, puffed up and crunchy. Kids and adults both want to try it, so the bag usually gets opened before the game ends.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  12. 12$20–30

    Portable power bank

    Every phone dies. Pick a slim one with the cable built in so there’s nothing to forget.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  13. 13$10–20

    Sunset lamp

    Throws a warm sunset glow on the wall. Teens use it for photos, adults use it to wind down.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  14. 14$20–30

    Matcha starter kit

    A bamboo whisk, bowl and scoop for this year’s favorite drink. Pretty enough to leave out on the counter.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  15. 15$10–20

    Mini waffle maker

    Small, cheap and always a hit. Waffles, hash browns and grilled cheese in a few minutes.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  16. 16$30–50

    Shiatsu neck massager with heat

    Kneads tight shoulders with gentle heat after a long day at a desk or behind the wheel. Anyone who tries it during the game wants to keep it.

    Steal rating: 5 out of 5

  17. 17$20–30

    Hues and Cues

    A color-guessing game that works for ages 8 to 80. Everyone gets it after one round.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  18. 18Under $10

    Exploding Kittens card game

    Fast, silly and easy to learn in a minute. It gets played at the party if someone opens it early.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  19. 19$20–30

    Owala FreeSip water bottle

    The bottle everyone seems to own in a different color. Sip or swig, and it doesn’t leak in a bag.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  20. 20$10–20

    Momofuku Chili Crunch

    Crunchy, garlicky chili oil that makes eggs, noodles and leftover pizza better. A pantry treat for anyone who likes a little heat.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  21. 21$10–20

    Hot sauce sampler

    A small box of sauces from mild to brutal. Bring a dare: who tries the hottest one first?

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  22. 22$20–30

    LEGO Botanicals succulents

    Nine little plants to build and arrange on a desk. Calm to build and impossible to kill.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  23. 23$10–20

    Instant-read meat thermometer

    Anyone who cooks at all will use it. It gets a shrug when it’s unwrapped and gets used more than anything else.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  24. 24$10–20

    Neck reading light

    Hangs around the neck and lights up a book or knitting without waking anyone. Night owls love it.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  25. 25$10–20

    Phone tripod with remote

    For group photos, video calls and cooking videos. Small enough to carry everywhere.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

  26. 26$10–20

    1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle

    Pick a fun, colorful one. A puzzle on the dining table gets the whole house involved over the holidays.

    Steal rating: 2 out of 5

  27. 27$20–30

    Pickleball paddle set

    Still booming

    A starter set for the sport that keeps growing. Easy enough for a total beginner, and fun for players who already have a regular game.

    Steal rating: 4 out of 5

  28. 28Under $10

    Biscoff cookie butter (giant jar)

    The spiced cookie spread in a jar big enough to share. A small gift that tastes like the holidays, and the jar never lasts long.

    Steal rating: 3 out of 5

What makes a gift work for anyone

A unisex gift passes a simple test: picture the five most different people at the party holding it. If every one of them would use it, eat it or put it on a shelf, it belongs here. Cozy things pass that test, treats pass it, and small gadgets that fix an everyday annoyance pass it.

What fails it? Anything sized, anything scented and anything that assumes a hobby. A fishing lure, a bath bomb set or a wine kit can be a great gift for the right person, but in a steal game you don’t get to choose who that person is. Searches for unisex White Elephant gifts jumped this season for that reason. Groups are bigger and more mixed, and nobody wants to bring the gift that sits unclaimed.

Trending picks that still work for everyone

Some of this year’s most-searched products are natural unisex gifts. Weighted stuffed animals, heated eye masks and the stacked-ring ski mug all climbed through the fall, and the porch goose craze turned a concrete lawn bird into the year’s favorite running joke. Collectibles like Smiski and the Tamagotchi revival appeal to adults and kids alike.

We left last year’s headline trends, Labubu and Dubai chocolate, off the top of this list. Searches for both have dropped sharply since last season, and Labubu fakes are still everywhere. If you want a blind box, Smiski and Sonny Angel are easier to buy from official stores.

Mixing funny and useful

The best unisex gifts often do both. An emotional support pickle gets a laugh when it’s unwrapped and then lives on a desk for a year. A Stanley tumbler looks like a fad and gets used every morning. If your gift is purely practical, like a power bank or hand warmers, a funny wrap or a joke card makes the reveal more fun.

Not sure of the budget for your group? Most mixed groups land between $20 and $30. Check the under $25 list for more at that price, or the family list if kids are playing.

Tips for this list

  • Blind boxes and plush have a counterfeit problem online. Buy Smiski from a retailer on the official Smiski where-to-buy list, Sonny Angel from the official Sonny Angel USA store, and Jellycat from jellycat.com.
  • Skip clothing sizes, perfume, scented candles and anything that depends on drinking. Those are the gifts that land with the wrong person.
  • Food is the safest unisex gift there is. If you’re stuck, a good treat plus a small cozy item covers almost everyone.
  • Wrap it in neutral paper. Pink or camo wrapping tells the room who you think it’s for before anyone opens it.

Before the party

Check the White Elephant rules so everyone plays the same way, use the number generator to draw the turn order, and if part of the group is remote, run it as a virtual White Elephant game.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good unisex White Elephant gift?

Something cozy, edible or fun that anyone could use: a weighted stuffed animal, a heated eye mask, a wearable blanket, a Stanley tumbler, a Tamagotchi or a box of freeze-dried candy. Avoid sizes, scents and hobby-specific gifts.

What gifts should I avoid in a mixed group?

Clothing with sizes, perfume and scented candles, alcohol, and anything tied to one hobby. They can be great gifts for the right person, but in a steal game you don’t choose who takes yours home.

Are blind boxes good unisex White Elephant gifts?

Yes. Smiski and Sonny Angel appeal to adults and kids, and opening them is fun to watch. Buy from the brand’s official store or listed retailers, because fakes are common online.

What is a good unisex gift for $25?

A heated eye mask, an Owala water bottle, an original Tamagotchi, rechargeable hand warmers or a Hues and Cues game all land around $20 to $30. Use the price buttons above to see only that range.

Is a funny gift or a useful gift better for a mixed group?

A bit of both works best. Something like an emotional support pickle or a hot cocoa bomb set gets a laugh and still gets used, so it keeps moving around the room.