White Elephant

White Elephant Gift Wrapping Ideas

The short answer

The best White Elephant gift wrapping hides the shape and adds a laugh: put the gift in a decoy box (a cereal box or a used appliance box), nest it in several boxes, mummify it in duct tape, or label it with a fake product name. Keep it openable in under a minute so the game keeps moving.

Last updated

On this page
  1. Decoy box
  2. Nesting boxes
  3. Duct tape mummy
  4. Fake label
  5. Weight trick
  6. Shape disguise
  7. Ugly sweater wrap
  8. Newspaper or comics
  9. Brown paper and a portrait
  10. Plastic Easter egg
  11. Tin can
  12. Ice block
  13. Puzzle box
  14. Gift wrapped in money
  15. Christmas stocking
  16. Mystery bag
  17. Lots of tiny parcels
  18. Fake handwritten card
  19. What not to do
  20. Pair it with a good gift

Wrapping is half the game in White Elephant. People pick from the pile based only on how a gift looks, so a clever wrap gets a laugh, a sneaky one causes a bad pick, and a heavy box gets grabbed first. Here are the ideas that work, grouped by what they do.

Decoy box

Put a small gift inside a box for something else: a cereal box, an old blender box, a box of “Industrial Grade Toilet Brushes”. Everyone thinks they know what it is until it’s open. Save shipping and appliance boxes through the year for this.

Nesting boxes

Wrap the gift, put it in a bigger box, wrap that, and repeat four or five times. The last layer should be the smallest. Cap it at five boxes, or the turn drags.

Duct tape mummy

Wrap the gift in a full roll of duct tape. It’s hilarious to watch and takes real effort to open. Pair it with a pair of safety scissors taped to the outside, or the oven mitt game for extra chaos.

Fake label

Print a convincing product label and stick it on plain paper: “Emergency Cheese, Do Not Open”, “Office Morale (Assorted)”, “One Year Supply of Dad Jokes”. It costs nothing and gets a laugh when the gift is picked.

Weight trick

Tape a brick, a bag of rice or a few cans inside the box, so a tiny gift feels heavy. Heavy boxes get picked early. Tell the winner it’s ballast so nobody thinks the brick was the gift.

Shape disguise

Tape a pool noodle, a paper towel tube or a balloon to the box so the outline gives nothing away. A gift card can become a lumpy, two-foot mystery.

Ugly sweater wrap

Wrap the gift inside an ugly Christmas sweater and tie the sleeves around it. Two gifts in one, and it fits an ugly sweater theme.

Newspaper or comics

Wrap in the Sunday comics, a map, or old sheet music. Cheap, a little retro, and good for a re-gift theme.

Brown paper and a portrait

Use plain kraft paper and draw a terrible portrait of whoever might end up with it. Or draw the gift, badly, on the outside.

Plastic Easter egg

Hide something small like a gift card or jewelry inside a giant plastic egg, then wrap the egg. The wrong holiday is part of the joke.

Tin can

Put the gift in an empty, cleaned can with a fresh label, or in a paint can from a hardware store. Pry it open with a spoon.

Ice block

Freeze a waterproof gift (a gift card in a zip bag works) in a block of ice and bring it in a cooler. Only for small groups and only if you can keep it frozen.

Puzzle box

Put the gift in a cheap puzzle box or a combination lock bag, and tape the code to the bottom of a different gift. Fun, but give a time limit.

Gift wrapped in money

Wrap a gift in a few dollar bills taped together. Expensive-looking, and a bonus for whoever wins it.

Christmas stocking

Stuff the gift deep into a stocking, then fill the top with candy and tissue. Holds odd shapes well.

Mystery bag

Everyone uses the same plain brown bag. Nobody can judge by the wrapping, so picks are truly random.

Lots of tiny parcels

Split a gift with several pieces (a cocoa kit, a candle set) into separate tiny parcels in one bag. Slow to open, which builds suspense.

Fake handwritten card

Add a card from someone fictional: “To my dearest nephew, enjoy the brick. Love, Aunt Linda.” It works with any of the ideas above.

What not to do

  • No name tags. The giver stays anonymous until the end.
  • Nothing that takes five minutes. One hard-to-open gift is fun; ten of them kill the game. Ask people to keep it under a minute.
  • No real hazards. No glitter bombs at an office party, no loose glass, nothing that leaks if it thaws.
  • Don’t wrap perishables in a way that hides them. Someone could leave it in a hot car.

Pair it with a good gift

A great wrap with a weak gift gets a laugh and then gets stolen away. Start with funny gift ideas or gifts under $25, then wrap it. If the whole party agrees a theme, the themes page has 25 to pick from. The standard White Elephant rules explain how wrapped gifts are chosen and stolen. Playing with people in different places? In the virtual White Elephant game, each gift stays hidden behind a wrapped card until it’s opened. For the turn order, use the free number generator.

Frequently asked questions

Should you wrap a White Elephant gift?

Yes. The game depends on gifts being a surprise until they're opened. Wrap it so nobody can guess the shape, and don't put your name on it.

What is a funny way to wrap a White Elephant gift?

The classics are a decoy box (a gift card inside a huge TV box), nesting boxes, a duct tape mummy, or a fake label like 'Assorted Regrets, 12 pack'. Each one gets a laugh before the gift is even out.

How do you wrap a White Elephant gift so it gets picked?

Make it look intriguing but not obvious: an odd shape, a heavy box, or a gift bag with a question mark tag. Very neat, expensive-looking wrapping also gets picked early, which can be a trap.

Can I use a gift bag for White Elephant?

You can, but stuff the top with tissue and tape it shut. An open bag lets people peek, which spoils the open-or-steal choice.