White Elephant

White Elephant vs Secret Santa (and Yankee Swap)

The short answer

In Secret Santa, names are drawn in advance and each person buys a gift for one specific person. In White Elephant, everyone brings one anonymous gift to a pile, then players take turns opening a gift or stealing one. Yankee Swap is White Elephant with a single final swap for the first player.

Last updated

On this page
  1. The quick difference
  2. How White Elephant works
  3. How Secret Santa works
  4. How Yankee Swap works
  5. Which should you pick?
  6. Other names you’ll hear

The quick difference

White ElephantSecret SantaYankee Swap
Who you buy forAnyone (gift goes in a pile)One person, drawn in advanceAnyone (gift goes in a pile)
Is it a game?Yes, open or stealNo, gifts are handed outYes, open or steal
StealingYes, usually capped at 3NoneYes
EndingFinal swap for player 1 (varies)Reveal who your Santa wasPlayer 1 gets one final swap
Gift styleFunny or broadly usefulPersonalFunny or broadly useful
Time at the party30–60 minutes10–20 minutes30–60 minutes
Best forOffices, big groups, mixed crowdsClose friends, small teams, familiesNew England offices and families

How White Elephant works

Everyone brings one wrapped gift within a budget. Players draw numbers. On your turn you open a gift from the pile or steal an opened gift from someone else. A gift usually freezes after three steals. The full version, with a worked example, is on the White Elephant rules page.

Good: nobody has to shop for a specific person, it’s entertaining for the whole room, and it scales to big groups. Watch out for: competitive stealing can upset people, so set the steal limit before you start.

How Secret Santa works

Each person draws a name (in a hat or with an online name generator) and buys a gift for that person. Gifts are exchanged at a party or left anonymously. Sometimes the Santa is revealed at the end.

Good: gifts are personal and thoughtful. Watch out for: someone forgets or drops out, gifts can be uneven, and it’s hard to buy for people you don’t know.

How Yankee Swap works

Yankee Swap is the New England name for the White Elephant steal game. The main rule difference is the ending: player 1, who had no chance to steal, gets one final swap with anyone. Read the full Yankee Swap rules.

Which should you pick?

  • Office party, people don’t know each other well: White Elephant. Use cozy rules (two-steal freeze, no final swap). The coworker gift ideas list is a safe place to start.
  • Small team or close friends: Secret Santa, if everyone will actually shop.
  • Big family with mixed ages: White Elephant or the dice game, so everyone plays at once.
  • Remote team: White Elephant, played live on the call with our virtual White Elephant game. Secret Santa also works remotely but has no shared moment.
  • Can’t decide: see all the gift exchange games side by side.

Other names you’ll hear

White Elephant is also called Dirty Santa, Thieving Elves and the Grinch Game, and Pollyanna in parts of Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Pollyanna can also mean Secret Santa there, so check which one your host means. The history is on why it’s called White Elephant.

Running White Elephant in person? Draw the turn order with the free number generator.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between White Elephant and Secret Santa?

Secret Santa gives each person a specific recipient drawn in advance, so gifts are personal. White Elephant uses a shared pile of anonymous gifts and a game where people can steal, so nobody knows who they're buying for.

Is Yankee Swap the same as White Elephant?

Almost. Both use a pile of wrapped gifts and stealing. In Yankee Swap, the first player gets one chance at the end to swap with anyone. Many groups use the two names for the same game.

Which is better for the office

White Elephant usually works better at work: nobody has to buy for a colleague they barely know, it's a shared event, and it takes under an hour. Secret Santa suits small teams that know each other well.

Can you do Secret Santa and White Elephant together?

Yes. Some groups do Secret Santa for a personal gift, then each person also brings a $10 gag gift for a short White Elephant round.