Ways to play

Ornament Exchange Game

The short answer

An ornament exchange is a White Elephant where every gift is a Christmas ornament. Guests bring one wrapped ornament, draw numbers, and on each turn open an ornament or steal one already opened. An ornament freezes after two or three steals, and everyone goes home with one for their tree.

Last updated

On this page
  1. How to play
  2. Budget and rules to put on the invite
  3. The poem version (no stealing)
  4. Ornament ideas people fight over
  5. The pickle tradition
  6. Remote family?

How to play

  1. Everyone brings one wrapped ornament within the budget. No names on the tags.
  2. Draw numbers for the turn order. The free number generator does it on one phone.
  3. Player 1 opens an ornament and shows it off.
  4. Each next player opens a new one or steals an opened ornament. If yours is stolen, you open or steal again, but you can’t steal straight back.
  5. An ornament freezes after two or three steals.
  6. Optional final swap: player 1 may swap once with anyone at the end.

It’s the same game as classic White Elephant. The White Elephant rules page covers disputes and edge cases.

Budget and rules to put on the invite

  • Budget: $10–$20 per ornament. Some groups go higher for nicer glass ornaments.
  • Steal limit: two steals per ornament, then it’s frozen.
  • Type: “store-bought or handmade, but it must hang on a tree.”
  • Wrapping: a box, so fragile ornaments survive being stolen.

Write the rules once with the house rules generator and share the link.

The poem version (no stealing)

Some families pass the ornaments while someone reads a poem or story with LEFT and RIGHT in it, like the Left Right Christmas game. When the story ends, you keep the ornament you’re holding. It’s gentler and good with young kids.

Ornament ideas people fight over

  • Personalized year ornament for the year (keep it general, not with a name)
  • Food ornaments: a tiny glass pickle, a slice of pizza, a donut, a taco
  • Nostalgic ornaments: a mini retro game console, a cassette tape, a classic toy
  • Hobby ornaments: a coffee cup, a tiny book stack, a camera, a bike
  • Handmade: salt dough, a painted wooden star, a felt animal
  • A nice glass ball from a local shop, with the shop’s name on the box

For more gifts that suit all ages, see family gift ideas, or the ornaments theme if you’d rather keep a classic White Elephant with an ornament theme.

The pickle tradition

Many families hang a glass pickle ornament on the tree, and whoever finds it first on Christmas morning gets an extra gift. A pickle makes a fun ornament to bring: wrap it with a note about the tradition.

Remote family?

You can run an ornament exchange on a video call: each person adds their ornament as a gift with a photo, and plays open-or-steal in the virtual White Elephant game. Givers ship the ornaments afterward. Compare other ideas on the gift exchange games page.

Frequently asked questions

How does an ornament exchange work?

It's White Elephant with ornaments only. Everyone brings one wrapped ornament, draws a number, and takes turns opening a new one or stealing an opened one.

How much should you spend on an ornament exchange?

$10 to $20 is typical. Set a budget on the invite so a $3 ornament doesn't end up next to a $60 glass one.

How many times can an ornament be stolen?

Most groups freeze an ornament after two or three steals. Two keeps it friendly and moving.

Can you do an ornament exchange with kids?

Yes. Use a two-steal limit, or skip stealing and play the Left Right story game with ornaments instead.